Confidence journal prompts

Joel Dean
Joel Dean, Founder of Joyful

Confidence journal prompts work best when they collect evidence instead of compliments. Confidence in a skill grows mostly from doing hard things and noticing that you did. These 14 prompts help you find that proof, borrow some from people like you, and plan the next small stretch.

How to use these. Name one area first: speaking up, dating, a new job, a sport. "Confidence" in general is hard to write about. Answer with facts, dates and names, and leave out the adjectives.

Proof you've already done it

Your own track record is the most dependable source of confidence.1 It's also the first thing you forget on a nervous morning.

A time I was nervous about something in this area and did it anyway: what happened, step by step?

Answer this with Joy

What can I do now that I couldn't do two years ago?

Answer this with Joy

What's a mistake I recovered from, and how long did the recovery take?

Answer this with Joy

Three times this month I handled something well, however small: ___.

Answer this with Joy

Someone like you who did it

Watching someone similar succeed makes the thing look possible, and the closer the match, the more it counts.1 A celebrity is too far away.

Who do I know, not a celebrity, who started where I am and got further?

Answer this with Joy

What did they do in their first year that I could copy?

Answer this with Joy

If I asked them how nervous they were at the start, what do I think they'd say?

Answer this with Joy

Words worth keeping

Feedback from someone who'd also tell you the bad news carries weight. Flattery doesn't.

What's a specific compliment I've received about my work or character that I quietly dismissed?

Answer this with Joy

Who gives me honest feedback, and what did they say the last time?

Answer this with Joy

If someone who believes in me watched me this week, what would they point out?

Answer this with Joy

Reading your nerves

Shaking hands before a match or a first date look like proof you aren't ready. Ready people get them too.

How does my body feel right before something hard: heart, hands, stomach, voice?

Answer this with Joy

Is the feeling more like dread or more like a race about to start, and could it be both?

Answer this with Joy

One small stretch

Add a little difficulty. Just a little.

One thing slightly outside my comfort zone I'll try this week, and when: ___.

Answer this with Joy

Afterward: what happened, compared with what I predicted?

Answer this with Joy

Bandura's four sources, in order

The groups on this page follow a 1977 paper by the psychologist Albert Bandura, who called confidence in a specific task self-efficacy and named four sources of it, in rough order of strength.1

  1. Mastery. Having done the thing, or something like it, and seen yourself get through.
  2. Watching someone like you. Their success makes yours look possible.
  3. Persuasion. What people you trust tell you.
  4. Your body's state. A racing heart can be read as fear or as readiness.1

The page ends with a stretch because that's a new mastery experience, the first source again. It's also why there are no "I am confident" lines here to repeat: for people who already feel low about themselves, repeated positive statements can backfire, as the positive affirmations page explains.2 A real memory gives your mind less to argue with.

Example entry: "Area: speaking up in meetings. Proof: in March I pushed back on the launch date and we moved it. My hands shook, and it still worked. Person like me: Ana, who was quiet her first year and now runs the Monday call. Stretch: ask one question in Thursday's meeting. After: asked it, and the room didn't go silent like I'd predicted. Kofi followed up on it."

  • Doing it: When did I do something like this before?
  • Seeing it: Who like me has done it?
  • Hearing it: What has someone I trust said about me here?
  • Feeling it: Could these nerves mean I'm getting ready?

When it's more than one skill

Doubt about your whole worth as a person is a self-love question, and the journal prompts for self-love fit it better. Feeling like a fraud despite clear success has its own set: the imposter syndrome prompts.

Fear of social situations that keeps you away from work, school or friends deserves more than a journal.

Questions people ask about confidence journaling

How long before a confidence journal makes a difference?

Give it a few weeks of entries. The value builds as the file grows: by then you have dated proof to reread the night before the next hard thing, and your own handwriting is harder to dismiss than someone's pep talk.

Do confidence affirmations work?

For some people they help, and for others they backfire.2 Lines built from your own real wins often land better. The affirmations for confidence page shows how to write them.

Can you be confident and still nervous?

Yes. Often at the same moment. Confidence is the belief that you can handle it, and a racing heart doesn't cancel that.

In the journaling section: journal prompts for self-love, journal prompts for imposter syndrome and affirmations for confidence.

Sources

  1. Bandura A. Self-efficacy: toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review, 1977;84(2):191-215. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.84.2.191
  2. Wood JV, Perunovic WQE, Lee JW. Positive self-statements: power for some, peril for others. Psychological Science, 2009;20(7):860-866. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2009.02370.x